(75 hours), with fresh shortening added twice daily to restore the fryer
volume (32). Sensory scores for fries showed few significant
differences whether they were fried in fresh shortening or in fat which
had been used for 10 days. In comparing the fries from the two
shortenings independent of the effect of days of fat use, panelists
judged the overall quality of the fries fried in canola shortening as
good or better than fries fried in soybean shortening. Subsequently,
Hawrysh (33) has shown that french fries of comparable quality were
produced from partially and fully hydrogenated canola and soybean
oils, and tallow. Warner et al. (34) reported higher flavour scores for
fries fried in LLCO and partially and fully hydrogenated LLCO than
RCO.
Environmental Frying Odour
Canola and soybean oils, when heated to frying temperatures develop a
strong unpleasant room odour so called because it lingers in the
frying environment rather than in the fried food. This odour has been
described as fishy, painty, plastic and burnt/acrid (35-37). It has been
attributed to the volatile products of thermal oxidation of linolenic
acid, since this same odour does not result from high temperature
heating of corn, peanut and cottonseed oils (38). Also, heating canola
oil experimentally under nitrogen reduces the off-odour (39). Studies
conducted with LLCO (34, 37, 39) have shown a significant reduction
in environmental frying odour.
Storage Stability of Fried Foods
The shelf life of fried snack foods depends, to a large extent, on the
quality of the frying medium because significant quantities of the
frying medium are absorbed by the food. Potato chips, for example,
increase in fat content from less than 1% to over 30% during frying.
Hawrysh et al. (40) tested the stability of potato chips which had been
fried in four different oils: canola, partially hydrogenated canola,
soybean and cottonseed, under two storage temperatures in the absence
of light: accelerated (60°C) for 12 days, and ambient (23°C) for 18
weeks. During accelerated storage, potato chip odour/flavour and off-
odour were not affected by oil type. However, after 18 weeks at room
temperature, chips which had been fried in canola oil had higher
typical potato chip odour/flavour and lower off-odour/flavour than
chips fried in the other oils. In contrast, Hawrysh et al. (41) reported
higher characteristic odour and lower off-flavour, rancid and painty
odours in tortilla chips fried in LLCO, corn oil and partially
hydrogentated canola and soybean oils than RCO after 16 days of
storage at 60°C. No differences were found among oil types for chips
stored at room temperature for 24 weeks. Warner et al. (42) also
reported potato chips fried in RCO had the lowest flavour quality
scores after four months of storage at 25°C compared to chips fried in
hydrogenated, low linolenic and high oleic canola oils. Similarly, RCO
chips had significantly higher amounts of total volatiles than the chips
fried in the other three oils, and high oleic canola oil (HOCO) and
LLCO chips had lower amounts of total volatiles than hydrogenated
canola oil. Petukhov et al. (43) found chips fried in RCO had greater
rates of accumulation of peroxides, free fatty acid, conjugated dienoic
acids and polar compounds and developed higher levels of total
volatiles over the 16 days of storage at 60°C than chips fried in
LLCO, HOCO and hydrogenated canola oil. Chips fried in all oils
except hydrogenated canola oil had similar rates of development in
painty odour as storage time increased. Chips fried in hydrogenated
canola oil exhibited an intense stale/musty odour by the end of 16 days
of storage.
Baking with Canola Oil Products
Traditionally cakes, cookies and pastries have been prepared by North
American consumers with plastic fats like shortening, lard or butter.
Shortening and lard are 100% fat products while butter is only 80%
fat. Plastic fats vary in consistency according to their temperature,
melting point and the proportion of oil globules within the network of
solid fat crystals which gives them structure. Canola oil is converted to
shortenings of predetermined consistency through controlled
hydrogenation, blending and aeration. Usually 5-10% of another oil,
such as palm, is added to assure a stable structure of microscopically
fine fat crystals (44).
The property of plasticity is particularly important in conventional cake
shortenings so that they can be creamed without liquefying to trap the
fine air bubbles which establish the cakes grain or cell structure.
Plasticity is influenced not only by the proportion of fat crystals but
also by their size and strength of association. When most of the fat
solids are in the form of small b ' crystals (<1mm) a shortening is more
plastic whereas if the larger b crystals dominate, it is more brittle (44).
Today emulsifiers and/or surfactants are routinely added to cake
shortenings to stabilize batter foams, assuring high baked volume and a
fine, even grain. They minimize somewhat the importance of a
shortenings crystal size to its creaming power. White cakes made with
emulsified canola shortening using an institutional cake recipe with
27% fat were fully comparable to cakes made with soybean shortening
in flavour, tenderness and fineness of grain (44).
Since the mid-1980s, one trend in commercial cake baking has been
to replace plastic fats with liquid oil in combination with appropriate
surfactants and increased levels of liquid. These fluid shortenings have
been shown in sensory evaluations to produce cakes which are
generally scored fresher, moister and more tender (45). Canola oil has
been shown to replace hydrogenated shortening very successfully in
white layer cakes when used with an emulsifier system of
monoacylglycerols, polysorbate 60 and sodium stearoyl lactylate.
Without the emulsifier system, oil cakes were dense and tough with a
harsh crumb. Including the emulsifiers as 9.5% of the flour weight
along with more water (169%), corrected these defects. The emulsified
oil cakes were more tender than the shortening prototype even when
the oil was reduced from 52.5% to 10.5% of the flour weight (46).
This offers an attractive market opportunity for light cakes. Sensory
quality is a high priority for dessert items. Consumers have been found
to sample, but not continue to buy, fat free or low-fat dessert items
when they are not satisfied with the taste (47).
Shortenings remain the fat of choice for pastry where fat is cut into the
flour to waterproof it intermittently, resulting in tender, flaky pie
crusts. Like lard, canola shortenings are generally less plastic than
some other shortenings and tend to have somewhat larger crystals,
properties that appear to be an advantage in pastry. Data from test
pastries comparing canola and soybean shortenings with lard are
shown in Table 2. While lard still produced the most tender product,
canola pastry was more tender than the soy product and just as flaky as
the lard pastry (44).